Is the quality revolver you get with the bandit background the same as the fine revovler you can make? It has the same stats, but does it have the same accuracy with magical creatures?
I believe that every weapon of a certain type is equally accurate unless it has a TH (to hit) modifier. I seriously doubt that Drog missed a value on the item proto that isn't reflected in the description. You can always just create both in WorldEd and compare the stats.